Showing posts with label Special Civil Actions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Special Civil Actions. Show all posts

Quo Warranto



What is a quo warranto?

1) Quo warranto is a demand made by the state upon some individual or corporation to show by what right they exercise some franchise or privilege appertaining to the state which, according to the Constitution and laws they cannot legally exercise by virtue of a grant and authority from the State (44 Am. Jur. 88-89).

▪ A proceeding or writ issued by the court to determine the right to use an office, position or franchise and to oust the person holding or exercising such office, position or franchise if his right is unfounded or if a person performed acts considered as grounds for forfeiture of said exercise of position, office or franchise. Quo warranto may also be used when an association acts as a corporation within the Philippines without being legally incorporated or without lawful authority so to act.

▪ A quo warranto is a prerogative writ by which the Government can call upon any person to show by what warrant he holds a public office or exercises a public franchise. (3 Moran 208 )


2)  It is a special civil action commenced by a verified petition against (a) a person who usurps a public office, position or franchise; (b) a public officer who performs an act constituting forfeiture of a public office; or (c) an association which acts as a corporation within the Philippines without being legally incorporated or without lawful authority to do so (Rule 66, Sec. 1).


Who may file a case for quo warranto?

1. The Solicitor General or a public prosecutor, when directed by the President of the Philippines, or when upon complaint or otherwise he has good reason to believe that any case specified in the preceding section can be established by proof, must commence such action. (Rule 66, Sec 2) (MANDATORY QUO WARRANTO) 

2. The Solicitor General or a public prosecutor may, with the permission of the court in which the action is to be commenced, bring such an action at the request and upon the relation of another person. (Rule 66, Sec 3) (DISCRETIONARY QUO WARRANTO) 

3. A person claiming to be entitled to a public office usurped or unlawfully held or exercised by another may also bring an action for QW in his own name. (Rule 66, Sec 5)


When government commence an action against individuals
(QW in the name of the Philippines)

1) Quo warranto is commenced by a verified petition brought in the name of the Government of the Republic of the Philippines by the Solicitor General, or in some instances, by a public prosecutor (Rule 66, Secs. 2 and 3). When the action is commenced by the Solicitor General, the petition may be brought in the Regional Trial Court of the City of Manila, the Court of Appeals or the Supreme Court (Sec. 7). 

2) An action for the usurpation of a public office, position or franchise may be commenced by a verified petition brought in the name of the Republic of the Philippines thru the Solicitor General against:

(a) A person who usurps, intrudes into, or unlawfully holds or exercises a public office, position or franchise;

(b) A public officer who does or suffers an act which, by the provision of law, constitutes a ground for the forfeiture of his office;

(c) An association which acts a corporation within the Philippines without being legally incorporated or without lawful authority so to act (Sec. 1).


When individual may commence an action for quo warranto
(QW in the name of a private individual)

The petition for quo warranto may be commenced by a private person in his own name where he claims to be entitled to the public office or position alleged to have been usurped or unlawfully held or exercised by another (Rule 66, Sec. 5). 

Accordingly, the private person may maintain the action without the intervention of the Solicitor General and without need for any leave of court (Navarro vs. Gimenez, 10 Phil. 226; Cui vs. Cui, 60 Phil. 37). In bringing a petition for quo warranto, he must show that he has a clear right to the office allegedly being held by another (Cuevas vs. Bacal, 347 SCRA 338). It is not enough that he merely asserts the right to be appointed to the office. 


Sol-Gen vs. Private Individual

Private individual – In petitions for quo warranto filed by a private individual, it is necessary for him to prove his right to the office. If he fails to prove, it is unnecessary for the court to pass on the right of defendant in office.

Solicitor-General – But when instituted by the Sol-Gen or the public prosecutor, it is not necessary that there be a person claiming to be entitled to the office alleged to have been usurped. The duty of the court is to pass upon the right of the defendant to the office. (Acosta vs. Flor, 5 Phil 18, 1905)


When to file

Action must be commenced within 1 year after the cause of such ouster, or the right of the petitioner to hold such office or position, arose. 

● The periods within which the quo warranto action should be brought are conditions precedent to the existence of a cause of action. The action cannot prosper beyond said periods even if such a defense was not raised by the defendant in the lower court (Abeto vs. Rodas, 82 Phil 59).

● The one-year period, however, is not interrupted by the prosecution of any administrative remedy as, in quo warranto proceedings, no one is compelled to resort to administrative remedies since public interest requires the right to public office should be determined as speedily as possible. (Galano vs. Roxas, L-31241, Sept. 12, 1975)


Where to file (venue)

1. Supreme Court
2. Court of Appeals
3. RTC where the respondent or any of the respondent resides
4. RTC, CA, SC (concurrent jurisdiction) - when Solicitor-General commences the action

5. Sandiganbayan (under R.A. 8249) - petition for quo warranto arising or that may arise in cases filed or that may be filed under EO 1, 2, 14 & 14- A

6. Municipal Trial Court (ONLY INSTANCE) - petition for quo warranto for the disqualification of an elected barangay official 


What is the nature or tenor of the judgment

When the respondent is found guilty of usurping into, intruding into, or unlawfully holding or exercising a public office, position or franchise, judgment shall be rendered that such respondent be ousted and altogether excluded therefrom, and that the petitioner or relator, as the case may be, recover his costs. Such further judgment may be rendered determining the respective rights in and to the public office, position or franchise of all the parties to the action as justice requires. (Rule 66, Sec. 9)


What are the rights of persons adjudged entitled to office?

If judgment be rendered in favor of the person averred in the complaint to be entitled to the public office, he may, after taking the oath of office and executing any official bond required by law:

1. Take upon himself the execution of the office;

2. May immediately thereafter demand all the books and papers in the respondent’s custody or control appertaining to the office to which the judgment relates; and

▪ If respondent refuses, he may be punished for indirect contempt. 

3. May bring an action against the respondent to recover damages sustained by such persons by reason of usurpation. (Rule 66, Sec. 10)

▪ The action for damages should be commenced within 1 year after the entry of the judgment establishing petitioner’s right to the office in question.  (Rule 66, Sec. 11)


Limitations:

1. Quo Warranto - file within 1 year from the date of usurpation
2. Damages - file within 1 year from entry of judgment (Rule 66, Sec. 11)


If there is a dispute between and among the Board of Directors of a private corporation, one group claiming that they have been usurped, is the proper remedy quo warranto?

No.  This is an intra-corporate dispute to be filed in the regular courts (RTC) having original jurisdiction


Peculiarities of Proceedings

1.  When the Solicitor General or a public prosecutor commences the action at the instance of another person, leave of court must first be secured.

2. The motion for leave must be set for hearing with notice to the respondent so that he may be heard.

3. The court issues the order allowing the filing of the action within the period fixed therein.


Quo Warranto as distinguished from Election Contest

ELECTION PROTEST
QUO WARRANTO
Proper remedy if the dispute is as to the counting of votes or on matters connected with the conduct of the election.  

An election contest challenges the right of a person to hold office on the ground of IRREGULARITIES in the conduct of the elections for said office.
Proper action when the dispute is on the INELIGIBILITY of a person sought to be ousted
In election contests, the successful protestant will ASSUME the office if he had obtained plurality of the valid votes
If the quo warranto proceeding succeeds, the respondent will be ousted but the petitioner will NOT ASSUME the office


Distinctions between Quo Warranto in elective and appointive offices

QW (ELECTIVE OFFICE)
QW (APPOINTIVE OFFICE)
The issue is the eligibility of the respondent
The issue is the validity of the appointment
The occupant who was declared ineligible or disloyal will be unseated but the petitioner will not be declared the rightful occupant of the office.
The court will oust the person illegally appointed and will order the seating of the person who was legally appointed and entitled to the office.


Quo warranto vs. Mandamus

QUO WARRANTO
MANDAMUS
Remedy to try disputes with respect to the title to a public office. The right to the office itself is disputed.
The remedy to oust the usurper where there is no dispute as to who has the title to the public office but the adverse party, without lawful ground, prevents the rightful occupant from assuming the office (Lota vs CA, L-14803, June 30, 1961)


Quo Warranto (Election Code) vs. Quo Warranto (Rule 66)

Quo Warranto (Election Code)
Quo Warranto (Rule 66)
To contest the right of an electoral   public officer to hold public office.
Prerogative writ by w/c the govt. can call upon any person to show by what title he holds a public office or exercises a public franchise
An electoral proceeding under the Omnibus Elections Code for the exclusive purpose of impugning the election of a public officer on the ground of ineligibility or disqualification to hold the office
Three grounds: usurpation, forfeiture, or illegal association
Petition must be filed within 10 days from the proclamation of the candidate
Presupposes that the respondent is   already actually holding office and action must be commenced within one year from cause of ouster or right of petitioner to hold office arose
May be filed by any registered candidate for the same office and, who, even if the petition prospers, would not be entitled for that office.
The petitioner must be the government or the person entitled to the office and who would assume the same if his action succeeds.


read more...

Interpleader


Interpleader

The action of interpleader is a remedy whereby a person who has property whether personal or real, in his possession, or an obligation to render wholly or partially, without claiming any right in both, or claims an interest which in whole or in part is not disputed by the conflicting claimants, comes to court and asks that the persons who claim the said property or who consider themselves entitled to demand compliance with the obligation, be required to litigate among themselves, in order to determine finally who is entitled to one or the other thing. (Ocampo vs. Tirona, G.R. No.147812. April 6, 2005)


Purpose of the remedy

The remedy is afforded not to protect a person against a double liability but to protect him against a double vexation in respect of one liability. (Ocampo vs. Tirona, ibid.)


Requisites for interpleader

1) There must be two or more claimants with adverse or conflicting interests to a property in the custody or possession of the plaintiff;

2) The plaintiff in an action for interpleader has no claim upon the subject matter of the adverse claims or if he has an interest at all, such interest is not disputed by the claimants;

3) The subject matter of the adverse claims must be one and the same; and

4) The parties impleaded must make effective claims.


Interpleader vs. Intervention
 
INTERPLEADER
INTERVENTION
1. an original action
1. ancillary action
2. presupposes that plaintiff has no interest in the subject matter of the action or has interest therein in whole or in part which is not disputed by the other parties
2. proper in any of the four situations: persons having (a) legal interest in the matter of litigation, or (b) success of either of the parties, or (c) an interest against both, or (d) is so situated as to be adversely affected by a distribution or other disposition of property in the custody of the court or of an offer thereof, (Rule 19, Sec. 1)
3. defendants are being sued precisely to interplead them
3. defendants are original parties to the pending suits


Procedural Peculiarities

1. Upon the filing of the complaint, the court shall issue an order requiring the conflicting claimants to interplead with one another.

2. If the interest of justice so requires, the court may direct in the same order that the subject matter of the suit be paid or delivered to the court.

3. The summons shall be served on the conflicting claimants together with a copy of the complaint and order mentioned in no. 1. (Serve: summons, complaint, order)

4. The defendants may file a motion to dismiss on the ground of:

a) the impropriety of the interpleader action or on 
b) other appropriate grounds specified in Rule 16.

5. The defendants shall serve a copy of the answer not only to the plaintiff but also to the other conflicting claimants who may file their reply thereto.

6. If any claimant fails to plead within the prescribed period, the court may, on motion, declare him in default and thereafter render judgment barring him from any claim in respect to the subject matter.


When to file to file an interpleader?

Whenever conflicting claims upon the same subject matter are or may be made against a person who claims no interest whatever in the subject matter, or an interest which in whole or in part is not disputed by the claimants, he may bring an action against the conflicting claimants to compel them to interplead and litigate their several claims among themselves. (Rule 62, Sec. 1)

Example:

A leased an apartment to B. So, pursuant to this agreement, B have been occupying this apartment paying the rentals.  After the lease period has run, let’s say, six (6) months, here now surfaces C. C said, “B does not pay anymore the rentals to A, this apartment is mine. Pay to me.” B is in a dilemma. If he (B) pays to A and it turns out later that C has a better right, he runs the risk of paying twice. If he pays to C, he runs the risks of paying again to A because C may not have the right.

Q. If you were B, what is the remedy available to you, so that regardless of who is the party  entitled to receive, you will be protected?

A. File a suit for interpleader. B vs. A and C. Why? So that A and C can fight it out in this case. So, B initiates the complaint against two (2) people who do not want to go to court and litigate.
               
So, this process of interpleader, A and C are compelled to fight each other. That is the concept of interpleader.


We now have this complaint by B against A and C.

Q. What is the prayer of B here?
A. That A and C be directed to interplead with each other. Meaning, that A and C should fight it out and have this matter of who is entitled to the rental. Actually, it is not B who is fighting A or C. It is A and C who are fighting each other.

Q. But who initiated the fight between the two (2)?
A. B.

Q.  What now is the procedure to be followed by the court when this interpleader action was filed? 
A. A and C will also be summoned under Rule 14. But with this difference: accompanying the summons is an order of the court.


Rule 62, Sec. 2

Upon filing of the complaint, the court shall issue an order requiring the conflicting claimants to interplead with one another. If the interests of justice so require, the court may direct in such order that the subject matter be paid or delivered to the court. 

So, the sheriff now serves on A and C the summons. Together with the summon is that order of the court directing A and C to interplead with one other. So, A will file his answer.

Q. Who will be furnished copy of the answer of A?
A. A will furnish B and C.

Q. C will file his answer. Who will be furnished with the copy of the answer of C?
A. A and B.

Q. Do you now see why this is a special civil action?
A. In ordinary civil action, do the defendants furnish each other copies of their answers? No except when the answer contains a cross-claim. But here, the defendants furnish each other. Why? Because they are the ones litigfating.

So, insofar as A is concerned, the plaintiff against him is C. Insofar as C is concerned, A is the plaintiff against him.


Q. May a motion to dismiss the action for interpleader be filed by A and C? Can A and C avail of Rule 16, before they file their answer?
A. Yes

Section 4 Rule 62

Within the time of filing an answer, each claimant may file a motion to dismiss on the ground of impropriety of the interpleader or on other appropriate grounds specified in Rule 16. The period to file the answer shall be tolled and if the motion is denied, the movant may file his answer within the remaining period, but shall not be less than five (5) days in any event, reckoned from   notice of denial.

Q. What do you notice with respect to the ground of a motion to dismiss an interpleader action and a motion to dismiss in an ordinary civil action?

A. In an ordinary civil action, the impropriety of the action is not a ground for a motion to dismiss. Under Rule 62, it is. So, the grounds for a motion to dismiss under Rule 62 are more encompassing than the ground of a motion to dismiss under Rule 16.


Sec. 5 Rule 62 covers that situation already mentioned earlier.

Sec. 5 Rule 62

Each claimant shall file his answer setting forth his claim within fifteen (15) days from service of the summons upon him, serving a copy thereof upon each other conflicting claimants who may file their reply thereto as provided by these Rules. If any claimant fails to plead within the time herein fixed, the court may, on motion, declare him in default and thereafter render judgment barring him from any claim in respect to the subject matter.


After A and C have been summoned, they will file their answer serving the plaintiff B and other defendants of the copy of the answer. In the answer of A and C, each will assert his right to the rental in this example. He will give his reasons why the rental should be paid to him.

Q. May A and C also file a counterclaim, a cross-claim?
A. Yes. 

Sec. 5 Rule 62

The parties in an interpleader action may file counterclaims, cross-claims, third-party complaints and responsive pleadings thereto, as provided by these Rules.

So, there is nothing special about this, except with this provision where they have to furnish each other with copies of their pleadings.

Q.  What now is the disposition of the court with respect to these cases?
A. After the pleadings of the conflicting claimants have been filed and pre-trial have been conducted in accordance with the rules, the court shall proceed to determine their respective rights and adjudicate their counterclaims.
   
            
Sec. 6 Rule 62

After the pleadings of the conflicting claimants have been filed, and pre-trial has been conducted in accordance with the Rules, the court shall proceed to determine their respective rights and adjudicate their several claims.

It means to say following the pre-trial, trial proper will now proceed. 

After the court has conducted the pre-trial and received the evidence, the court will now determine who between A and C is entitled to this rental. And of course, will adjudicate the counterclaims.
 
    
Sec. 7 Rule 62

The docket and other lawful fees paid by the party who filed a complaint under this Rule, as well as the costs and litigation expenses, shall constitute a lien or change upon the subject matter of the action, unless the court shall order otherwise. 


Cases:

Menzi & Co. vs. Bastida, 63 Phil 16 – The costs, expenses and attorney’s fees incurred by the plaintiff in the action is recoverable from the defendant who loses in the action and is found by the court to have caused the unnecessary litigation.

Beltran vs. PHHC, L-25138, August 28, 1969 - Action for interpleader is improper where defendants have conflicting claims against the plaintiff.

Vda. De Camilo vs. Aranio, L-15653, September 29, 1961 - Where there are no conflicting claims among the defendants, their respective claims being spearte and distinct from each other, the complaint for interpleader may be dismissed for lack of cause of action.

Wack-Wack Golf & Country Club vs. Lee Won, L-23851, March 26, 1976 - An action for interpleader must be filed within a reasonable time after the dispute has arisen, otherwise it may be barred by laches. Where a party was aware of the dispute and in fact had been sued by one of the claimants and the former did not implead the other claimant, he can no longer invoke the remedy of interpleader.

read more...

Declaratory Relief



What is the subject matter in a petition for declaratory relief?

The subject matter in a petition for declaratory relief is any of the following:

a) Deed;
b) Will;
c) Contract or other written instrument;
d) Statute;
e) Executive order or regulation;
f) Ordinance; or
g) Any other governmental regulation (Rule 63, Sec. 1).


What is the issue in the action?

The issue is the validity or construction of the above documents.


What is the relief sought?

The relief sought is the declaration of the petitioner’s rights and duties under the said documents.

● The purpose is to seek for a judicial interpretation of an instrument or for a judicial declaration of a person’s rights under a statute and not to ask for affirmative reliefs like injunction, execution, damages or any other relief beyond the purpose of the petition as declared under the Rules.

● The purpose is to ask the court to make a proper interpretation of a written instrument (deed, will, contract, or any other written instrument) or a statute, executive order, ordinance, or other governmental regulation.

● An action for declaratory relief is brought to secure an authoritative statement of the rights and obligations of the parties under a contract or a statute for their guidance in the enforcement or compliance with the same (Meralco vs. Philippine Consumers Foundation, 374 SCRA 262).


Who may file the action

1. Any person interested under a deed, will, contract or other written instrument

2. Any person whose rights are affected by a statute, executive order or regulation, ordinance or other governmental regulation (Rule 63, Sec. 1)

● Those who may sue under the contract should be those with interest under the contract like the parties, the assignees and the heirs as required by substantive law (Art. 1311, Civil Code).

● If it be a statute, executive order, regulation or ordinance, the petitioner is one whose rights are affected by the same (Rule 63, Sec. 1). The other parties are all persons who have or claim any interest which would be affected by the declaration. The rights of person not made parties to the action do not stand to be prejudiced by the declaration (Rule 63, Sec. 2).


Where to file the petition?

RTC. (Rule 63, Sec. 1)


When to file the petition?

Petition for declaratory relief is filed before there occurs any breach or violation of the deed, contract, statute, ordinance or executive order or regulation. (Rule 63, Sec. 1) It will not prosper when brought after a contract or a statute has already been breached or violated. If there has already been a breach, the appropriate ordinary civil action and not declaratory relief should be filed.

The concept of a cause of action as “an act or omission by which a person violates the right of another” under ordinary civil action does not apply. In declaratory relief, there must be NO breach or violation of the instrument or statute involved.

GR: Declaratory relief is available BEFORE there is actual breach or violation of an instrument or statute.

Exceptions:

Declaratory relief may still be availed even if there is breach or violation IF:

1. it concerns future application of the instrument or law (Gomez vs. Palomar, 25 SCRA 827) or

2. not objected to by the adverse party and the court has rendered judgment after full blown trial (Matalin Coconut Producers,143 SCRA 1)


Requisites of action for declaratory relief

1) The subject matter must be a deed, will, contract or other written instrument, statute, executive order or regulation or ordinance;

2) The terms of said document or the validity thereof are doubtful and require judicial construction;

3) There must have been no breach of the documents in question;

4) There must be actual justiciable controversy or the ripening seeds of one between persons whose interests are adverse ( there is threatened litigation the immediate future/there must be allegation of any threatened, imminent and inevitable violation of petitioner’s right sought to be prevented by the declaratory relief sought);

5) The issue must be ripe for judicial determination (as for example, where all administrative remedies have been exhausted);

6) adequate relief is not available through other means or other forms of action or proceeding. (Ferrer and Espera vs. Roco, Jr. G.R. No. 174129, July 5, 2010)


When court may refuse to make judicial declaration

The court, motu proprio or upon motion, may refuse to exercise the power to declare rights and to construe instruments in any case where:

a) A decision would not terminate the uncertainty or controversy which gave rise to the action; or

b) The declaration or construction is not necessary and proper under the circumstances (Rule 63, Sec. 5).

    e.g. when the instrument or the statute has already been breached 

In declaratory relief, the court is given the discretion to act or not to act on the petition. It may therefore choose not to construe the instrument sought to be construed or could refrain from declaring the rights of the petitioner under the deed or the law. A refusal of the court to declare rights or construe an instrument is actually the functional equivalent of the dismissal of the petition.

On the other hand, the court does not have the discretion to refuse to act with respect to actions described as similar remedies.

What are the actions described as similar remedies which the court may not refuse to render judgment?

a) Action for reformation of an instrument;
b) Action for quieting of title; and
c) Action to consolidate ownership 

Conversion to ordinary action

If before the final termination of the case, a breach or violation should take place, the action may thereupon be converted into an ordinary action, and the parties shall be allowed to file such pleadings as may be necessary or proper. (Rule 63, Sec. 6) This is to avoid multiplicity of suits (Republic vs. Orbecido, G.R. No. 154380, Oct. 5, 2005).


Ordinary Action vs. Declaratory Relief
  
 
Ordinary Civil Action
Declaratory Relief
1. writ of execution is available
1. writ of execution is not available
2. there is a breach or violation of a right
2. there is no breach or violation of a right
3. grounds for dismissal – Rule 16
3. grounds for dismissal –
a. Rule 16
b. Additional grounds
- Where the decision would not terminate the uncertainty or controversy which gave rise to the action; or
- Where the declaration or construction is not necessary and proper under the circumstances.


Declaratory Relief Improper in the Following Cases:

1) to obtain judicial declaration of citizenship;

2) to seek relief on moot questions or to resolve hypothetical, abstract or theoretical questions, or to decide claims which are uncertain;

3) to resolve political issues or questions;

4) to test the correctness or validity of a court decision;

5) to determine hereditary rights;

6) when the petition is based upon the happening of a contingent event;

7) when the petitioner is not the real party in interest; and

8) when administrative remedies have not yet been exhausted (enumerations from Feria, p. 437)


Procedural Peculiarities

1. The petition must be filed before there is a breach of contract or violation of the statute or ordinance.

2. Third-party complainant is not allowed

3. Except in actions for quieting of title, the court action on an action for declaratory relief is discretionary. Thus, the court motu proprio or upon motion may refuse to exercise the power to declare rights and to construe instruments in any case where a decision would not terminate the uncertainty or controversy which gave rise to the action or in any case where the declaration or construction is not necessary under the circumstances.

4. When a statute, executive order or any government regulation or ordinance is alleged to be unconstitutional, the Solicitor-General should be notified by the party assailing the same. If the validity of a local government ordinance is in question, the prosecutor or attorney of the local government should be notified.


Reformation of an instrument

1)  It is not an action brought to reform a contract but to reform the instrument evidencing the contract. It presupposes that there is nothing wrong with the contract itself because there is a meeting of minds between the parties. The contract is to be reformed because despite the meeting of minds of the parties as to the object and cause of the contract, the instrument which is supposed to embody the agreement of the parties does not reflect their true agreement by reason of mistake, inequitable conduct or accident. The action is brought so the true intention of the parties may be expressed in the instrument (Art. 1359, CC).

2) The instrument may be reformed if it does not express the true intention of the parties because of lack of skill of the person drafting the instrument (Art. 1363, CC). If the parties agree upon the mortgage or pledge of property, but the instrument states that the property is sold absolutely or with a right of repurchase, reformation of the instrument is proper (Art. 1365, CC).

3) Where the consent of a party to a contract has been procured by fraud, inequitable conduct or accident, and an instrument was executed by the parties in accordance with the contract, what is defective is the contract itself because of vitiation of consent. The remedy is not to bring an action for reformation of the instrument but to file an action for annulment of the contract (Art. 1359, CC).

4) Reformation of the instrument cannot be brought to reform any of the following:
(a) Simple donation inter vivos wherein no condition is imposed;
(b) Wills; or
(c) When the agreement is void (Art. 1666, CC).

Consolidation of ownership

1) The concept of consolidation of ownership under Art. 1607, Civil Code, has its origin in the substantive provisions of the law on sales. Under the law, a contract of sale may be extinguished either by legal redemption (Art. 1619) or conventional redemption (Art. 1601).

Legal redemption (retracto legal) is a statutory mandated redemption of a property previously sold. For instance, a co-owner of a property may exercise the right of redemption in case the shares of all the other co-owners or any of them are sold to a third person (Art. 1620). The owners of adjoining lands shall have the right of redemption when a piece of rural land with a size of one hectare or less is alienated (Art. 1621).

Conventional redemption (pacto de retro) sale is one that is not mandated by the statute but one which takes place because of the stipulation of the parties to the sale. The period of redemption may be fixed by the parties in which case the period cannot exceed ten (10) years from the date of the contract. In the absence of any agreement, the redemption period shall be four (4) years from the date of the contract (Art. 1606).

When the redemption is not made within the period agreed upon, in case the subject matter of the sale is a real property, Art. 1607 provides that the consolidation of ownership in the vendee shall not be recorded in the Registry of Property without a judicial order, after the vendor has been duly heard.

2) The action brought to consolidate ownership is not for the purpose of consolidating the ownership of the property in the person of the vendee or buyer but for the registration of the property. The lapse of the redemption period without the seller a retro exercising his right of redemption, consolidates ownership or title upon the person of the vendee by operation of law. Art. 1607 requires the filing of the petition to consolidate ownership because the law precludes the registration of the consolidated title without judicial order (Cruz vs. Leis, 327 SCRA 570).

Quieting of title to real property

1) This action is brought to remove a cloud on title to real property or any interest therein. The action contemplates a situation where the instrument or a record is apparently valid or effective but is in truth and in fact invalid, ineffective, voidable or unenforceable, and may be prejudicial to said title to real property. This action is then brought to remove a cloud on title to real property or any interest therein. It may also be brought as a preventive remedy to prevent a cloud from being cast upon title to real property or any interest therein (Art. 476).

2) The plaintiff need not be in possession of the real property before he may bring the action as long as he can show that he has a legal or an equitable title to the property which is the subject matter of the action (Art. 477).

read more...